|
East dealer
|
|
North-South vulnerable
|
|
|
|
The bidding:
|
|
|
|
East
|
South
|
West
|
North
|
|
Pass
|
1NT
|
Pass
|
3NT
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Declarer's first aim is to make his contract. At no time should the matter of potential overtricks influence his plays, since the value of a game, a slam or even a partscore far exceeds the value of an overtrick.
Consider today's deal where South is in 3NT and West leads a club. East takes the king and returns a club to West's ace. West continues with a club to South's queen, East discarding a spade. How should declarer proceed?
There is no doubt that many players would at this point cross to dummy with a heart or a spade, lead the queen of diamonds and finesse. If they did this, they would go down one after West took the king and cashed his clubs.
However, the line of play is contrary to the principle stated above. There is no harm in crossing to dummy and leading the queen of diamonds, but it is wrong to finesse. The right play, after East follows low is for declarer to go up with the ace.
As it happens, the ace catches West's king and South ends up making 5NT, but the fact that the king falls does not in itself prove the play is right. There is a far better reason than hindsight for playing the ace.
Declarer should conclude that if East has the king, he will still make 3NT (with an overtrick) by continuing the suit after the ace fails to fell the king. But if West has the king, the contract can be saved if the king happens to be a singleton. This latter possibility is something declarer is duty-bound to protect against.
Source: Steve Becker, Globe and Mail, June 2, 2026
|