Royston (Herts) Bridge Club
Release 2.19r
0 0 0 0 0 0
Pages viewed in 2025
Andrew Robson Column 24th February 2020
Andrew Robson Column 24th February 2020


This is the version of Hand of the Month for 3rd October 2019, as written up by Andrew Robson for his Times column, published 24th February 2020. Comparing it to the original, the hands are rotated to make South declarer, and the bidding has been revised, in particular to suppress the opposition's final [unwise] double of the freely-bid slam. Andrew's column reads as follows:

 Bridge   Andrew Robson        

Reader Dave Simmons reports this interesting hand from a Royston Bridge Club teams event, in which North's Michaels bid helped to propel his side to the 19-count slam. 

Plan the play in 6 on a diamond lead. [ Click on Show Answer (below) when you've decided. ]
 

[ Bidding notes: ]

2 by W —  Not strong enough for 2♣, West contents himself with a weak raise, planning to bid clubs later.

3 by N —  Michaels, showing five-five (or longer) in both majors.

5by N —  Clearly, North is going to bid on with his extra shape. His 5 bid shows potentially slammy values.

6 by S —  South could have a lot less for his 4 bid, so accepts the slam try.

Pass  —  East correctly refrains from doubling.

As Simmons eloquently puts it: "Suppose the slam goes one down, non-vulnerable... you gain an extra 50 points; whereas if it makes, declarer makes an extra 230 points (1210 instead of 980).  Odds of roughly 5-1 against the double paying off."

Simmons continues: "In fact, a penalty double can potentially cost a lot more than that. Suppose that the double alerts declarer to a bad trump break, or gives declarer a clue to the winning line. If they now make a contract that would have gone down if passed out quietly, the loss is in fact 1,210 against a gain of 50.  Were you really that confident you'd defeat the slam?"
 

Your best chance of avoiding a heart loser is to cash the ace, succeeding when the king is singleton either side. The alternative of running dummy's queen wins only when specifically West holds a singleton jack, half as likely.

However, cashing the ace of hearts will not be so clever if East holds KJx, as you will lose two tricks. You can be sure of avoiding two heart losers by leading low towards dummy, or (slightly better because you avoid a loser entirely when East holds a singleton king), lead low from dummy and cover East's card.

Because the way to tackle hearts varies according to how many heart tricks you can afford to lose, you should take the spade finesse at trick two. You win the ace of diamonds and lead a spade to the queen (or run the jack).

When the queen of spades wins, you know you can afford a heart loser. At trick three, you lead the two of hearts and, when East plays the three, you in turn cover with the four, earning style points for winning the first round of trumps with the four, when West discards. [ Click on Show All Hands to reveal the East-West cards. ]

You can now cash the ace of hearts and set up spades, crossing to the ace (in case East forgot to win the king last time), ruffing a third spade and conceding only the king of hearts. Slam made. 


(C) Andrew Robson, 2020