Board 17 on Monday morning, the 27th of October, is a hand I am kicking myself over. Nevertheless, it reinforces a point I know and should have employed just before I started to play, namely THINK.
Sitting North with 11 points, 5 spades and non vul I decided I had 1 chance to bid, so I opened 1 NT in the hopes of pre-empting the opps. (I can’t open 1 spade, as I have no rebid….playing 4 card majors, 1 s, 2s, would be ok)
Maureen sitting East, with a lovely shapely hand and 12 points, correctly bids 2 hearts (multi Landy, showing 5 of the major and an unspecified minor)
My partner Helena, sitting South now has a dilemma; she knows we have some game, but what is it? She has some options here, as a bid at the 3 level in our system is now a game force. (We can use Lebensohl if we just want to compete) However, she decided with the Jack of hearts in her hand which is a half stop, to bid 3NT.
At this point Maureen’s partner Patricia, with only 3 points is silenced, so here I am in 3NT.
When Helena’s hand went down on the table, I must confess I felt some indignation…..imagine putting me into 3 NT with 3 hearts to the Jack! She doesn’t even know I have the Ace! etc etc. Then I thought well I have to take some of the blame bidding 1 NT with 11 points. It’s really my own fault. Sure enough I went down 2 giving the girls a top. Sad, but even sadder when I looked at the sheet and discovered, there were 10 tricks available to me. How?
Well instead of occupying my mind with pointless self pity at the start, I should have planned. Maureen led a low heart and Patricia went up with the Queen. I held up and held up again when Patricia returned a heart to Maureen’s King and then Maureen played another heart taking my Ace and Helena’s Jack at the same time. What I should have done of course, was to take Patricia’s Queen with the Ace, recognizing that Maureen would hardly have bid hearts without at least 1 honour in her hand. Therefore Helena’s Jack is now a stopper in the heart suit.
If I take my heart Ace at trick 1, I now play on the spades till the Ace is played. Maureen can play her king of hearts if she likes but now my Jack is good. So I get 2 hearts, 4 spades and 3 diamonds, maybe 4 diamonds or a club, for 9 or 10 tricks. I’m a dope!
Incidentally holding up the Ace often IS the correct play as you are hoping to cut communication between the opposition hands, but in this instance it was incorrect. The trick is to identify the different situations.
Most pairs played this contract in 2 spades by South. (South opens 1 NT and North transfers them to spades.) I can’t understand how they finish there though. If my partner opens 1NT, I will transfer and then invite by bidding 2 NT. Helena will bid 3NT with 14 points but only 2 spades. So we will end up in the same place anyway.
Mary Deane
|